So I've been eyeing this one for awhile. In recent memory, this has been one of the most contested apps, both among the council and the community at-large. To run down each of the individual bits play-by-play;
- Your app/story were a little on the mediocre end of things. And I don't think it was for a lack of effort, per se, just a lack of understanding our expectations.
- Your answers to the questions have been mostly solid, and most important in the way you responded is your attitude. You've handled yourself pretty well throughout the criticisms/litany of questions.
- In-game, you're pretty OK. I haven't seen you too often, but you understand the gist and do an adequate job.
All-in-all, it left me pretty neutral in opinion. And with split community input and a council split down the middle, neutral isn't really an opinion a tiebreaker is allowed to have. But I think Frans summed it up best; you have potential, and the best way to show off that potential is via a trial-by-fire. I'm going to extend you a
+1 and the opportunity to show your supporters and/or detractors that you have what it takes.
Congratulations. That being said, given the nature of whitelist apps and how close this one is, it may or may not be subject to the Whitelist Maintainer for further review - entirely at their discretion. In the meantime, keep playing Command and getting that experience - there's more work to be done.
PS: Even I OB'd the FOB when I had
my CO app up. Happens to the best of us B)