Rules chapter 13 : The unclear and the Unwritten

[Tharinoma]

What are the rules you think are unclear, and should be more clear?
What are the rules you think are unwritten, and should be more writen?

Speak now or be forever condemned to salt in ahelps before you get banned.

[Heraclitus]

Autism forts on the Almayer, what is one and are they allowed?

As a marine when can I, if ever, kill another marine on purpose (outside of mutinies)?

[Akabinxstar]

I'll get back to you when I get hit with a ban for a rule I haven't seen yet

[CABAL]

Rule 1 needs to be REMOVED!

But for real:
Rule 2 is a joke. It has nothing made clear and also it is broken by staff themselfs with santa hats and shit. If rules have to be clear, they have to have addition of "Admeme/Devmeme can break it as much as he wants and you can't do anything to it".
It doesn't say that it doesn't apply to benos, it doesn't say anything.

Rule 4: Mainly EORG. What is the point of it really? Just make that server doesn't register any combat logs after round end and that every rule (Besides rule 1, 3, 8 and 9) can be broken. What does it matter what marine did after round end? It's not like admemes do any mini-events, or anything after that. Nobody will be hurt by dying literally 1 minute before server restarts.

Rule 5: It should be changed as in current form it is archaic and it is obvious. What is not obvious, is that it should be about beno and marines (but mainly benos) abusing gameplay mechanics. Mechanics like benos corner-dragging marines out of the cades, or Walling off corpses.

Rule 6: Remove examples of vent welding and "Ramboing". Add atleast one example of benos Metagaming and one example of marines not Metagaming.

Rule 13: Hostile Humans should totally be able to bypass this rule on marines and vice-versa.

Rule 16: Allow CO to designate someone to do BE. It can be only one person, but still. It's ridiculous that CO has to wait for Marine to return to the ship when he is undermining his command, or sparking mutiny groundside.

Rule 17: Add few examples of bad and good mutiny reasons. Change that winning side leader can decide who is to be revived and who is not. Why aCO and higher has this right if he wins, but if he not, nobody has?

Add to roleplay standards to both Marines and Benos that excessive memeing is bad.

[Tharinoma]

Autism forts on the Almayer, what is one and are they allowed?

ok

As a marine when can I, if ever, kill another marine on purpose (outside of mutinies)?

Already in rules

[Tharinoma]

Rule 1 needs to be REMOVED!

No

But for real:
Rule 2 is a joke. It has nothing made clear and also it is broken by staff themselfs with santa hats and shit. If rules have to be clear, they have to have addition of "Admeme/Devmeme can break it as much as he wants and you can't do anything to it".
It doesn't say that it doesn't apply to benos, it doesn't say anything.

Rule 0

Rule 4: Mainly EORG. What is the point of it really? Just make that server doesn't register any combat logs after round end and that every rule (Besides rule 1, 3, 8 and 9) can be broken. What does it matter what marine did after round end? It's not like admemes do any mini-events, or anything after that. Nobody will be hurt by dying literally 1 minute before server restarts.

Thread isn't about changing rules only rewording them

Rule 5: It should be changed as in current form it is archaic and it is obvious. What is not obvious, is that it should be about beno and marines (but mainly benos) abusing gameplay mechanics. Mechanics like benos corner-dragging marines out of the cades, or Walling off corpses.

Ok

Rule 6: Remove examples of vent welding and "Ramboing". Add atleast one example of benos Metagaming and one example of marines not Metagaming.

Don't see the need

Rule 13: Hostile Humans should totally be able to bypass this rule on marines and vice-versa.

Thread isn't about changing rules only rewording them

Rule 16: Allow CO to designate someone to do BE. It can be only one person, but still. It's ridiculous that CO has to wait for Marine to return to the ship when he is undermining his command, or sparking mutiny groundside.

Thread isn't about changing rules only rewording them

Rule 17: Add few examples of bad and good mutiny reasons. Change that winning side leader can decide who is to be revived and who is not. Why aCO and higher has this right if he wins, but if he not, nobody has?

Don't see the need/Thread isn't about changing rules only rewording them

Add to roleplay standards to both Marines and Benos that excessive memeing is bad.

"Mentally Stable and fit for duty". Ok for xenos

[Akabinxstar]

Reword powergaming already, because you guys say it's doing stuff outside your role, but then you say its doing stuff to gain an unfair advantage, like which one is it, either way you need to specify

[Tharinoma]

Reword powergaming already, because you guys say it's doing stuff outside your role, but then you say its doing stuff to gain an unfair advantage, like which one is it, either way you need to specify

yes okay

[WitheredGryphon]

I don’t know if this qualifies as rewording, some admins/mods read Rule 6 to include Metarushing, some don’t. It needs to be cleared up whether metarushing qualifies under that rule. Also, if it does qualify, then specifically defining what a “metarush” is.

[Tharinoma]

I don’t know if this qualifies as rewording, some admins/mods read Rule 6 to include Metarushing, some don’t. It needs to be cleared up whether metarushing qualifies under that rule. Also, if it does qualify, then specifically defining what a “metarush” is.

Problem bigger than just rule wording, being worked on