Originally Posted by
Enyonggg
Based on my experience on Solaris round where you playing as Executive under Captain Nathon.
You frequently ignored your Squad Leaders and their analysis of the situation on the ground. You also ignored your SO. The result was you ordering an offensive for far longer than it was sustainable, and failing to organise an evacuation, leading to a total planetside wipe. Don't just rely everything to the CO. You're rife with indecision. Referring back to the excessively prolonged offensive, you got caught up in an argument about what actually to do, rather than committing to any serious action. You did not communicate with your squads. Had you done so, you would have noticed that Bravo or even other squad reported a breach every area of the FOB, but you didn't. Even if you did notice the breach, you did not retract the order and organise an evacuation as you should have done so. You rely again everything to the CO. You seemed to have a lack of understanding in the basics of overwatch itself and even then, you freaked a little bit when you weren’t able to understand what was wrong and to me, this could present a problem in itself as a CO later on.
Tbh, I politely suggest gaining more experience first, as your understanding of the actions that the marine mass and the community, in general, will take under different situations seems very lacking. Your leadership and communication also seem to be slightly sub-standard, you should talk to your squad more when you are overwatching, and provide them with more valuable intel, such as where the other squads have reported the enemies to be and taking the initiative to issue flanks and other orders.
Therefore, I don't think you are personally ready for CO. I believe you need a little more time in Command positions to really show whether or not you have the stuff. I've observed a couple rounds with you as XO now and I have not been impressed, no hard feelings.
-1, need to maintain our Highest Standard on this WL like before. Also, we don't need more COs who all the marines hate as soon as they walk out of cryo. Sorry not sorry.