A CO does not have to go exactly off how their character roleplays on the application, the only CO requirements we had for awhile was they had to stick to one character name, but council loosened up that requirement. Going off your application with how you roleplay is not a server rules violation.
The only roleplay that meets the level of RP standards violation is if you just meme and commit "LRP" acts not befitting your role. A CO belittling a subordinate is not a violation, now a player following another player being an absolute dick is a violation (Acting like the drill sergeant from Full Metal Jacket) but as I've said no server rules were broken in this instance.
Please await council decision.