Player Report
Your Byond ID? Cpkeyes
Date of Incident October 16, 2021
Your Character Name? Tabatha Ahuva Cody.
Accused Byond Key(if known): ZAB1019.
Accused Character Name Nordica Northey
Approximate time and date of the incident (Central US Time for fastest results) 10pm CST
What rule(s) were broken: Rule 4, 11.
Description of the incident: I was the only command staff of the round, and thus felt that I needed to depend more on the information provided by SL's and had to pull double duty as the OB loader as there was no MT or CE. This entire time, Northey was being aggressive towards my character, calling them "retarded" and other such things.
The straw that broke the camels back for me was me requesting for more information on the front, Northey responded by insulting me. I told her that her job was to provide information as a SL, in which they responded by continuing to insult me and tell me to check the tactical map (Which personally, I find doesn't give me the information I want to make a call). She also told me that "She was just there to shoot stuff".
I took this as to mean that she just wanted to play Private+ and thus field demoted her, and proceeded to ignore her as Northey had seemed to establish that she wasn't going to be useful.
Apparently this strike a nerve, as Northey began to rally a mutiny with marines I suspect did not fully know why she was doing it (apparently bad mortars were blamed on me, but I don't know if this is true). Apparently for most of them, were frustrated about my command, which fine, I don't agree with most of their points, that seem to be based off them not knowing what I was doing or just plain bias (Such as bad OB calls, which I don't see how the XO is responsible for), but those aren't the problem and I won't go into those reasons nor am angry at them, I as feel those are not the real reason ZAB wanted to do the mutiny.
It's Northey and the fact that the munity was basically just to "own" me and 'shitposting'. It was the fact that even with reason it was allowed, even through mutinies with better reasoning have been denied and it is feels like a admin-approved grief.
As far as I'm concerned, the trouble with Northey was over the moment I demoted her. She did not need to steal the Alamo and leave several marines to die, she did not need to steal my tablet just to rub salt in the wound and seeing as her one of her posts in this very chat is to 'legalize LRP', I don't see this as being anything but an attempt to troll.
There is also the problem I have with the fact I feel this shows a flaw in the mutiny guidelines. I may do a staff report, but I Frozentbgg did not understand the situation, and as he said in PMs to me "I don't think i'd approve a mutiny like this if it happened again to say the least) and apologized to me for being griefed, and even noted this is "Nordica being Nordica'.
That seems to make it clear to me that mutiny guidelines should be changed or made more clear, as a person who admits to being LRP, who is noted by other for looking for reasons to mutiny whenever they can, should clearly be given a tighter leash when they try to start a mutiny.
Evidence (screenshots, logs, etc):
How you would punish the accused: More scrutiny for munity requests, clearer guidelines, for ZAB, a job ban from SL, perhaps having a tighter leash for mutiny baiting.