Alright we in the council debated this for a while and have come to a conclusion.....
[17:08:49]SAY: Cyrus Saint/Chaznoodles : If you call a full evac, I will come up to the CIC and turn your head inside out.
Chazz. This right there makes you valid for a BE, one of the very first insults and disrespects you told Tom Dinkle was that you were going to go up and murder the commanding officer of the ship and in the process invert his skull and brain matter. Which is just.....not smart at all when trying to avoid BEs. Literally everything else you said and did just added onto the pile.
As for tom antagonizing you all round, its very hard not to antagonize you chazz, but tom was extremely patient when dealing with you. Even after you threatened to murder him and insulted him four or five times, he offered you the choice to apologize and all would be forgiven, you declined that choice and decided to continue your tirade, and thus you got BEd, the Battlefield execution was of course valid as seen in the video you were not under arrest.
So to sum up
BE was valid. Rule sixteen was NOT broken.
Tom did not ruin your round, you ruined your round. Threatening to kill the commander and then getting BEd is not a rule 3 violation.
I would say im not sure what you expected but you admitted it yourself:
"How you would punish the accused:
Implying there's ever a punishment."
All in all we in the co council recommend no action be taken against dinkle, have a CM day folks.